Dharmarakshavedi

Menu

HINDUS ARE TRIBALS, HINDUS ARE PAGANS

At the 5th Gathering of the Elders (Mysore, 1-4 February 2015), I was originally only present as an observer. But when a Hindu lady speaker had addressed the social philosophy of the Gond tribe, I felt it necessary to give a fitting reply, as it was contrary to the whole aim and spirit of the conference. To my good fortune, the next speaker failed to show up, so the chair asked me if I could improvise a lecture.

How deep the Christian missionary influence has penetrated the Hindu psyche, was shown by this rendering of their worldview. The first aim of the missionaries is to convince the tribals that they are not Hindus. (After that, they will tell them that their religion is very close to Christianity, that their self-acknowledgment as Hindus would constitute a “conversion” while their baptism would only constitute a “fulfilment” of their natural religion.) So, the lecture on the Gonds taught us that their religion is the very opposite of Hinduism because:

· 1. they worship Barâ Dev while Hindus worship Ishwar;

· 2. They consider the North auspicious; Hindus, the South;

· 3. They bury their dead; Hindus cremate them;

· 4. They believe in service to others (“jai seva!”), Hindus only in their own Liberation;

· 5. They believe the world is real, Hindus believe it is Maya (illusion).

· 6. They are divided in 12 exogamous phratries, Hindus in endogamous castes.

Against this, we notice that:

· 1. Barâ Dev, “great god”, is modern Indo-Aryan for Sanskrit Mahadeva, same meaning and a name for Shiva (“the benefactor”, which itself is a flattering name for the fearsome god Rudra, “furious”), for whom another name is Ishwar (“lord”). Within Hinduism, it is perfectly normal for a god to have different names, and for different divine personalities to overlap. There is simply no opposition between Barâ Dev and Mahadeva.

· 2. In Vastu Shatra, a front-door should not be built in the south, as it is deemed inauspicious, which is the same valuation of the south as among the Gonds. (For now, I take the speaker’s word for what exactly constitutes Gondi culture.) Even if it was different, it wouldn’t constitute a meaningful contrast: in China, the local habitat edology (fengshui) holds the south as positive and as the correct location of the front-door, due to a different climate: I the cold Yellow River valley, warmth was welcome, so the sunny south was good, whereas in hot India, men shield themselves against the sun. Yet, nobody derives therefrom a meaningful contrast between Indian and Chinese traditions, least of all the missionaries. Whether Chanakya or Confucius, all non-Christians are going to hell.

· 3. Hindus since Vedic times have known both cremation and burial. Infants and saints are still buried. In some corners, Hindu burials persist, e.g. among the Gonds.

· 4. Hindu society has always believed in social responsibility (Dharma, ca. “taking up your role as a specific part of the whole”), including the need for Seva, “service”, a genuine and ancient Sanskrit word (in contrast with Adivasi, “aboriginal”, which is a neologism devised by the missionaries in the colonial period). This was not put in the centre, and rightly so, but it was fully accepted. This duty was not discharged by clerics, as in Christianity, where hospitals were traditionally manned by nuns, but by laymen, mostly in the extended family. Ascetics, by contrast, were freed from social duty because they had taken up another duty, viz. pursuing Liberation, which to the laymen is mostly but a theoretical goal which they don’t actively pursue. Liberation is not “selfish” but impersonal, and requires a great deal of self-abnegation, even more than Seva.

· 5. Only a small percentage of the Hindus even know about Mayavad, the doctrine that the world is a fata morgana created by the magic power of the gods. It is a specific philosophy of Shankara, conditioned by his struggle against Buddhist idealism (Shunyavad, “doctrine of Emptiness”), which in turn is also not the whole of Buddhism (indeed, the Buddha himself would not have recognized it as his own teaching). Shankara is widely appreciated as a great debater and as the founder of the ascetic Dashanami order, but his philosophy has few takers. Gonds too are free to follow Mayavad, nothing prohibits that, but they too would by and large accept the world as real. And anyway, even if there were a difference in worldview pitting all Gonds against all Hindus, that would not save them: as long as they don’t believe in Jesus, they are all going to hell.

· 6. The Gonds are, like most tribes, an endogamous group, and this group is internally divided in twelve exogamous groups, which anthropologists have called phratries. Hindu castes are by definition endogamous groups, Jati-s or “castes”, and are divided in exogamous groups called Gotra-s. If you consider each caste separately, you could, by this logic, start saying that they “don’t have caste”, because internally they are not divided in endogamous groups, only in exogamous groups. So, the situation among the Gonds is exactly like in Hindu castes. Tribals are just as endogamy-conscious as Hindus. When a Flemish Jesuit in Chotanagpur ca. 1890 wanted to put his converts to the test, he had them sit together across tribal lines for a joint meal, a very small matter compared to intermarriage, and even this they found scandalous, so that most invitees did not show up and 7000 converts in the region defected. It is one of the many myths professed by the secularists to spite the Hindus that tribals are “noble savages” practising Ur-communism and not afflicted by social divides like caste.

The whole discourse on tribals is warped by the Aryan invasion theory. As a consequence of the hypothesis that speakers of proto-Sanskrit entered India ca. 1500 BC, the American situation is projected onto India: in both cases, a European population came to dominate the natives. Then, just like the European conquerors of America were considered civilized and Christian, while the Amerindians counted as tribal and Pagan, this cultural equation was projected onto India: the Vedic conquerors were non-tribal and non-Pagan, while the natives count as tribal and Pagan. So, working inside this paradigm, the missionaries tell the scheduled tribes to maximize their differences with the Vedic backbone of Hinduism, and the secularists have written a few times that Hindus cannot count as Pagans and that tribals who get “sanskritized” into the Vedic mainstream are “converts to Hinduism”.

The picture becomes very different when, as all evidence indicates, the Vedic Aryans were native to India. This implies that there simply were different tribes, including the Veda-composing Paurava tribe, some of which became more “civilized” than others, e.g. some became literate, others only later, yet others not until the modern state foisted literacy upon them; or some developed business acumen while others remained economically naïve. This is a normal development found on all inhabited continents.

That is why many features deemed tribal and contrasting with the image a foreigner gets of Hinduism when the taxi brings him from the airport to his hotel in the metropolis, also appear in Vedic tradition when you go and see it in the countryside, or when you study how it was in the past. Thus, worship in the open air is not a tribal feature contrasting with Hindu temple worship: in Vedic society, worship was equally in the open air. The tribal feature of aniconic nature worship, always contrasted with the Hindu worship of idols, was just as much in evidence in Vedic society and is still seen in the “primitive” layers of Hinduism, where you fing snake worship, tree worship, sun worship, etc.

Yet, even if there had been an Aryan invasion, that would not have made the Vedic Hindus any less demonic. We have heard here testimonies from Latvian and Lithuanian Pagans, who take pride in their language being closely akin to Sanskrit. They are not Indian, yet they are just as much Pagan. If the Vedic Aryans had contrasted with the native Indian tribals, if they had been different in all objects and practical details of worship and of mores, that would still not have saved either the one or the other from hellfire. For that is ultimately the criterion for being Pagan or not, regardless of all the distinctions invented to confuse matters. You are a Pagan if you do not partake of Christian salvation, i.e. if you go to hell. And that is where they belong: being to a smaller or larger extent fire-worshippers, Pagans must feel most at home in the endless fires of hell.

koenraadelst.blogspot.in
Koenraad Elst

Categories:   ലേഖനങ്ങൾ

Comments

  • Posted: August 31, 2016 19:08

    Aaliyah

    Could you please repeat that? buying amoxicillin online uk LONDON, Sept 20 (Reuters) - Royal Bank of Scotland could create an internal "bad bank" to house more of its problemloans, even if Britain decides not to enforce a breakup of thepart-nationalised lender, banking industry and political sourcessay. prematurex australia As directed by versatile James Mangold (“Walk the Line,” “Cop Land”), these developments feel remarkably grounded — almost as much of a leap beyond “X-Men,” in this respect, as “X-Men” was in comparison to its genre predecessors. A sequence with Wolverine battling Yakuza gangsters atop a speeding Shinkansen bullet train is a stunner, and a tender moment with Mariko schooling him on polite chopsticks form is nicely handled.
  • Posted: September 1, 2016 10:15

    Abdul

    Do you know what extension he's on? triverex canada Best of all, there is a staggering amount of content. Parents need not worry that their kids will have this one polished off by dinner time on Boxing Day - Swap Force features at least a dozen hours of main story (with immense replayability to achieve 100% completion) plus many hours of time challenges, arena battles, bonus levels, and more. can i buy domperidone over the counter in the uk Nothing is more terrifying than having to meet the payroll every month, come what may. Salaries sometimes have to be paid directly from owners’ bank accounts; the job is all-consuming and all-defining. Entrepreneurs are never off duty.
  • Posted: September 2, 2016 02:21

    Aaliyah

    Can I use your phone? super filagra next day uk Business tourism in Germany generated 57.2 billion euros ($76.7 billion) in 2012, figures from the national tourist board DTZ show. In that year 2.6 million trips from European countries were made to shows and exhibitions in Germany, a 9.2 percent increase from the previous year. fematril australia At least one plane was preparing to depart at the time of the evacuation, but Stewart said he did not know if it already had pulled away from the gate at the time of the evacuation. No flights were allowed to take off following the evacuation.
  • Posted: September 4, 2016 23:19

    Aaron

    Best Site Good Work essay writing about my teacher my hero The two-year conflict has killed 100,000 people inside Syriaand the violence has spread across the Lebanese border, withrocket attacks in the Bekaa Valley, street fighting in theMediterranean cities of Sidon and Tripoli and bombs in Beirut. dissertation problem statement Judge Raffaele Felice Pirro of the federal court in Riodismissed the case after accepting an "adjustment of conduct"accord with Chevron that commits the company to spending about300 million reais in compensatory activities and said thatTransocean had no responsibility for the spill.
  • Posted: September 8, 2016 13:36

    Abdul

    Do you know each other? harga misoprostol malaysia It would be a long, but clearly marked, road to success. Leonard began selling his work to Hollywood on a regular basis. When his next novel, The Moonshine War sold, he wrote the screenplay. Screenwriting would give him the income to pursue his real goal: writing novels full time. 52 Pickup was published in 1974, the first of several novels set in his hometown, Detroit. He read The Friends of Eddie Coyle by George V. Higgins and credits Higgins with showing him how to “loosen up” his writing and “get into scenes quicker.” lamisil 1 hinta Agence France-Presse is a global news agency delivering fast, in-depth coverage of the events shaping our world from wars and conflicts to politics, sports, entertainment and the latest breakthroughs in health, science and technology.
  • Posted: September 9, 2016 23:15

    Aaliyah

    We need someone with qualifications zyprexa rxlist The deeper cuts in council budgets were signalled in a speech by Local Government Minister Lesley Griffiths to the Welsh Local Government Association annual conference in June this year, where she said that the relative protection Welsh councils had enjoyed compared to their English counterparts since austerity began can no longer be sustained.
  • Posted: September 25, 2016 18:40

    Abraham

    I love the theatre purchase peptides tamoxifen review Thousands make the perilous crossing each year, seeking a new life in the prosperous European Union. Smugglers charge thousands of dollars a head for the journey aboard overcrowded, barely seaworthy boats that lack life vests. cleocin acne scars “Our son is a surrogate baby and the entire process is bound by strict confidentiality. We would appeal to all, to allow us to cherish this private moment as a family,” his statement went on to say. bisacodyl zetpil zonder recept "Without the Jessops being open in some of the neighbouring towns and cities like Banbury and Oxford, we are getting a lot of people travelling good distances because we do what they can't find in their own towns now," says Mr Peckham. fluticasone nasal spray over the counter uk Thirteen-year-old Luis Diaz, who was wearing a black-and-white photo of Andy taped to his t-shirt, said he waited in vain for his best friend to come over after school on Tuesday, not realizing until hours later that Andy had been shot. buy duloxetine hci Across the board we found that identical twins tend to be much more similar to one another than fraternal twins in terms of their levels of disordered eating and thin ideal internalization, and this suggest genetic influences on these phenotypes since identical twins share a much larger proportion of their genes than fraternal twins. Our group has one adoption study as well, where we looked at siblings who were both adoptees, so they weren’t genetically related at all compared to siblings who were regular biological siblings, and we found the same sort of pattern—the regular biological siblings were more similar in their disordered eating than non-related adopted siblings. precio cytotec colombia When the legendary closer realized what was happening, with both teams lining the dugout railings and applauding him, Rivera bowed and waved, to the crowd and his fellow players, and found himself fighting back tears. voltaren uses side effects The government has long argued on the grounds of national security that the surveillance courts' proceedings must be secret. Public and political reaction to Snowden's revelations has put pressure on that position.
  • Posted: September 26, 2016 21:46

    Abraham

    One moment, please bactrim topical antibiotic While Rodriguez’s ordeal has played out in dramatic fashion, Braun’s advisers worked quietly behind the scenes to negotiate a deal after MLB presented doping evidence gathered in its probe of Biogenesis and its owner, Anthony Bosch. how much does generic prozac cost without insurance "Rolls-Royce remains fully committed to this importantmarket segment and will continue to invest in technologies thatwill enable us to take advantage of opportunities as theyarise," the British company said. celecoxib 100mg pfizer By 2050, the coolest summers in the tropics and parts of the northern hemisphere will still be hotter than the most scorching summers since the mid-20th century if global warming continues apace, according ... metaxalone itching Liang Hong, vice president and operations manager of GSK(China) Investment Co Ltd, offered details on how he funnelledmoney through travel agencies by arranging conferences, some ofwhich were never held. sandoz-olanzapine odt 5mg Understanding how that happens is just one of the questions the Voyager team will attempt to figure out while the probe still has power. Voyager 1, and a sister spacecraft Voyager 2, use heat released by the natural decay of radioactive plutonium to generate electrical power for their instruments.
  • Posted: October 3, 2016 07:58

    Aaliyah

    Special Delivery viagra jak dziaa na modych Guy Cheron, a neurophysiologist at the Université Libre de Bruxelles, gives a clue as to how that can achieved: “We know that the signals we are sending to the eye arrive to the retina in a given wavelength. The brain then has to match the wavelength to be able to read those signals we send. As we, researchers and neuroscientists know these wavelengths, we can eventually filter them from all signals coming from the brain, and to retain only the waves with that particular wavelength And those are the brain waves that can eventually be used to control the exoskeleton.” anyone used testofuel "On virtually every page of the complaint, the trustee describes the many procedures and controls that the defendants put into place," they said. "Indeed, the complaint ... shows that the defendants were at all times working to transform MF Global into a profitable business." deer antler spray 60 min The program could also help businesses target their advertising campaigns for customers checking in on mobile devices. Mobile is an important channel because more than 50 percent of consumers use mobile phones while shopping in a store, Cisco said. priligy costo venezuela The United States currently uses more energy for air conditioning than all other countries combined. But as economic conditions improve in other large and hot countries, an increase in the use of air conditioning may put an unprecedented demand on the global energy supply, according to a researcher from the University of Michigan. how long to give lasix iv push The miner boosted iron ore output by 41 percent in the yearto end-June, nearing a target rate of 155 million tonnes a yearby end-December. In June, it shipped at an annualised rate of120 million tonnes, 5 million tonnes above target.
  • Posted: October 10, 2016 17:36

    Aaron

    I never went to university pe min kan wan post nasal drip "We will not be silent; we will not obey; we will not allow our government to destroy our humanity," Kokesh says in the video while loading the shotgun and standing in a plaza between the White House and the Capitol. "We are the final American Revolution. See you next Independence Day." pfizer genotropin pen for sale ‘Your GP practice may not be a designated yellow fever vaccination centre, so although they may provide all your other travel advice and any vaccinations you require, they won’t be able to administer yellow fever vaccination.’
  • Posted: October 11, 2016 17:04

    Aaliyah

    Languages order prednisone without rx Cummings' efforts, he added, also help remind black people that "we did come out of slavery but it wasn't all because of black power and black ingenuity prednisone reviews for bronchitis dosages On Friday, Sucart takes the first step toward removing the burdensome legal collar he has been saddled with since his arrest last Aug zithromax 250 mg 6 tablets 1 z pak Eager to impugn the motives of a group seeking to expand educational opportunity for disadvantaged New York children, Mayor de Blasio is calling on a pro-charter-school advocacy organization to disclose its donors.
  • Posted: October 12, 2016 06:59

    Abraham

    I need to charge up my phone is accutane safe 2014 This is a type of cookie which is collected by Adobe Flash media player (it is also called a Local Shared Object) - a piece of software you may already have on your electronic device to help you watch online videos and listen to podcasts. testerone sign and symptoms Una O’Brien CB, Permanent Secretary at the Department of Health, visited Wansbeck General Hospital to meet health and social care staff employed by Northumbria Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust – one of the only NHS Foundation Trusts to provide adult social care, as well as hospital and community care. furadantine voorschrift nodig "It's hard to do what they are trying to do. All of themhave been able to demonstrate quality and outcomes success. Andmost were able to demonstrate some improvement in the coststructure. Some saw a lot of improvement. A few did not meet thecost target." flagyl cause bladder infection The Federal U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Washington,D.C. found that the ITC erred when it invalidated one Applepatent and found that Motorola didn't infringe another. Thecourt returned the case to the ITC for further analysis of thoseissues, under different legal standards. qui prend ou a pris du duphaston But in one of the filings, the SEC said it was "unable toreach a settlement" with the Bents. The SEC also asked U.S.District Judge Paul Gardephe not to approve the relatedclass-action accord because resolution of its claims mightaffect the distributions available for investors. skelaxin tab It is not clear whether her apparent ties to the Bo family stretch back that far but it was in Liaoning that Mr Bo’s political career began, first as mayor of Dalian from 1992 until 2000, and then as provincial governor until 2004. precio atorlip At the end of the study, the relief from muscle stiffness was twice as high among the cannabis extract group in comparison with the placebo group. Muscle stiffness was alleviated in just under 30% of those given cannabis compared with just under 16% of those treated with the placebo.
  • Posted: October 12, 2016 12:51

    Abram

    An envelope amoxicillin capsules ip used for In an event of default, they may have to get rid ofdefaulted securities. But it does not necessarily mean panicselling because the rule states the disposal should take place"as soon as practicable", unless the board of directors findsthat a disposal would not be in the best interests of the fund. differin el 30g cena The good news for the Yankees is that Ivan Nova seems to have turned a corner toward realizing his potential, this being his fourth straight strong outing since being reinserted into the starting rotation. dose maxima ibuprofeno gotas While rumors swirled back in July of an 'I do,' Anna Faris and fellow actor Chris Pratt have now officially confirmed to People.com that they did indeed get hitched in August. 'The House Bunny' actress and the 'Parks and Recreation' star held a small ceremony in Bali on July 9th. kaiser ziach preis Under the new regulation, apple juice containing more than 10 parts per billion could be removed from the market and companies could face legal action. Agency officials stressed that the vast majority of juices on the market are already below the threshold. pristiq effexor dose conversion They were echoing the view from on high. Peer Steinbrueck has ruled out participating in another grand coalition under Mrs Merkel. His ally, Frank-Walter Steinmeier, the leader of the SPD in parliament, is also thought to be sceptical about the possibility. revatio buy online When her death became imminent she stopped writing and instead received a constant stream of friends . Even as she “turned her face towards Jerusalem” (as she put it when she decided to stop chemotherapy), she continued to delight with her eloquence and humour. manforce 100 mg capsule One of the 14 trusts investigated, Basildon and Thurrock University Hospitals NHS Foundation trust, had 1,600 more deaths than would have been expected in seven years, according to the Sunday Telegraph.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: